The conversion debate rolls on and on

Published: 10:16AM Jan 19th, 2012
By:

ALAN BARNES attempts to justify conversions by presenting the old chestnut that ‘the owner, having paid his money, has every right to treat the engine in whatever manner he thinks fit’ and that ‘a converted engine is surely better than an unconverted engine being cut for scrap’.

The reality is that there are very few engines which would have been scrapped if they had not been converted. Moreover, when you buy an engine, you buy the responsibility and duty to conserve the heritage which it represents. Conversion of an engine to something it never was in its working life is, quite simply, the destruction of heritage. It takes place because the rally movement has developed a kind of ‘celeb culture’ which is often seen as more important than heritage.

Conversions seldom look right, they often seem to be out of proportion somehow. So perhaps rally organisers should include an Ugly Corner or Freak Show at their events, where conversions can be displayed and visitors can go and have a good laugh at them.

Lyndon Shearman,
Elland, Yorks

0 Responses to “The conversion debate rolls on and on”

Comments

Please login or register to post a comment

Current Issue: May 2014

Issue May 2014

♦ 116-page bumper issue
♦ Lottery gives £469k to train new boilersmiths
♦ The Clayton from Sandy Bay
♦ Archive: Dustcarts and sweepers
♦ Titanic Belfast: Two years on and a riveting success
♦ Kew Bridge reopens
♦ Fowler plougher Bob changes hands
♦ Leicestershire memories
♦ Steam legend: Steve Neville ♦ 'Best of British' Leyland
♦ Cornish milestones ♦ Fowler R Compound
♦ News & events ♦ Steam archive

PLUS:

Buy this issue now

• Next issue on sale: May 15, 2014

Issue 291

Issue 291
May 2014

When Britain was workshop to the world

Subscribe and get this issue

Buy it now facebook Sample on-line

Other Letters

Shearer steam cars in Oz

I HAVE been a member and volunteer of the Queensland Maritime Museum in Brisbane since settling here in 2001. ...

Read More »

Engine and thresher are Foden products

FURTHER to the request made by Roy Fletcher (Helpline OG 285), I can confirm that his grandfather’s engine is ...

Read More »

View all...

Advertisements

Related magazines:

Heritage Commercials magazine The Railway magazine Wrights Farming Register

 

Use our handy tool to find your nearest stockist!
Find your nearest Stockist

Read on-line as a digital issue:

Available on the Android Marketplace

Available on Pocket Mags

Advertising Deadline:

Trade Advertising Deadlines:
June 2014 - April 29, 2014
July 2014 - June 3, 2014
For more information contact our Advertising representative

To book free classifieds use our online form:

Book advertising here

Next Issue Out:

May 15, 2014